NewsLocal News

Actions

'You have flawed evidence': Prosecutors request new trial in the Adnan Syed case

Adnan Syed and 'Serial': What you should know
Posted at 10:24 PM, Sep 14, 2022
and last updated 2022-09-15 15:28:24-04

BALTIMORE — State Prosecutors have found errors in a case that is over 20-years-old for a man that is currently spending life in prison.

Maryland Prosecutors asked a judge Wednesday to overturn the murder conviction of a man whose case was made nationally known by a murder podcast.

Baltimore City State's Attorney has filed a motion to vacate the conviction for Adnan Syed, a man who was found guilty for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee back in 1999.

Court documents state Lee was last seen at Woodlawn High School in January, weeks later her body was discovered buried in Leakin Park. Her cause of death was found to be strangulation.

Syed was sentenced to life in prison, but questions were raised in the case about some of the evidence used, after national recognition from the podcast "Serial" in 2014.

Now, after a year long investigation, prosecutors say new evidence is being presented and they are calling for a new trial.

"It's not every day that the prosecutors office is the one that files the motion in the interest of justice and I tip my hat to them for pursuing justice rather pursuing a conviction here," said Dr. Jeff Kukucka, Professor of Psychology at Towson University.

Doctor Kukucka is a professor of psychology at Towson University, specializing in the study of wrongful convictions.

He says science has progressed significantly in the last 20 years.

"We know a lot more know about the flaws of eyewitness memory, the shortcomings of forensic science than we did back in the late 90's,” said Kukucka.

Syed was 17-years-old when the murder occurred.

RELATED: Prosecutors move to vacate Adnan Syed's lifetime murder sentence

Prosecutors are stating that Syed’s conviction was based on one witness's unreliable testimony along with misleading forensic science.

They are now questioning unreliable cell phone tower data and pointing toward two other suspects who they say had motive, one in which threatened to make the victim disappear, material that was never disclosed during the trial.

"A Brady violation basically just means that the prosecution in the case failed to turn over relevant information to the defense so the defense did not have that information available to them," said Kukucka.

Doctor Kukucka says these are some of the most common factors found in wrongful conviction cases and when all three happen at the same time it brings reason to doubt the conviction.

"It really feels like the perfect storm for a wrongful conviction, you have a prosecutorial misconduct in the form of a Brady violation, you have a unreliable witness testimony, and you also have flawed or misleading evidence," said Kukucka.

Prosecutors say they are not stating Syed is innocent, he just deserves a fair trial.

Syed is still claiming his innocence.

Back in March, Lee's clothing was tested for “touch DNA” which was unavailable at the time of the trial. No useful results were found.

More samples are still being reviewed.