NewsRegionBaltimore City

Actions

Three men exonerated 36 years after being convicted of teen's murder

Officers: Marilyn Mosby not immune from lawsuit
MEN EXONERATED
men exonerated
Posted at 5:41 PM, Nov 25, 2019
and last updated 2019-11-26 10:36:28-05

BALTIMORE — Three men have been exonerated, 36 years after being convicted of murdering a 14-year-old Baltimore teenager.

"This journey here for us has been rough,: said Ransom Watkins. "We outside them walls, but on the inside I hate to put it like this we went through Hell. It wasn’t easy. You see us out here we’re smiling, we’re happy that we’re free but we got a lot to fix.”

Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins, and Andrew Stewart, were arrested on Thanksgiving Day in 1983.

They were each found guilty of shooting and killing DeWitt Duckett at Harlem Park Junior High School, over a Georgetown jacket the victim was wearing.

Their case was re-opened by Baltimore City State's Attorney Marilyn Mosby's Conviction Integrity Unit after Chestnut called expressing the three men's innocence.

“These three men were convicted, as children, because of police and prosecutorial misconduct. What the state, my office, did to them is wrong. There is no way we can ever repair the damage done to them. We can’t be scared of that and we must confront it,” said Mosby in a press conference alongside the three men. “I want to thank these men from the bottom of my heart for persevering for decades to prove their innocence. They deserve so much more than an apology. We owe them real compensation - and I plan to fight for it.”

The convictions were based on the testimony of four teenage witnesses who have since recanted, saying they were pressured by police to change their initial accounts.

After Duckett's murder, three of the four witnesses originally told police that one person had committed the crime, not the three boys.

A teacher said that Watkins, Chestnut, and Stewart, who were no longer students at the school, had been in the building shortly before the crime.

Signs pointed toward Chestnut even more after he was seen wearing a Georgetown jacket like Duckett's. His mother however, was able to provide a receipt for the jacket.

The initial three witnesses failed to identify the three boys from a photo array, and at least one of them identified someone else.

A few days later though, a school security guard told police that a 14-year-old girl could identify the three boys.

Police then brought the other three witnesses back to the station for questioning, at which point they said Watkins, Chestnut, and Stewart committed the murder.

In May 1984, the jury deliberated for only three hours before convicting all three boys, who had claimed innocence from the beginning.

“I’m looking forward to living the rest of my life being as humble and peaceful as I am praising god and looking out for my family," said Chestnut. "Oh man I’m telling you it’s out of this world.”

During a Monday press conference, Mosby announced the creation of a new program to help those exonerated, to transition back to society.

“Today isn’t a victory. It’s a tragedy that these three men had 36 years of their life stolen from them,” said Mosby. “On behalf the State's Attorney office, let me say to these three men, I am sorry. The system failed you. You should never have seen the inside of a jail cell.”

Mosby also officially launched an effort for legislation that would compensate those who are wrongfully convicted.

The State's Attorney says she will also push for improved juvenile justice rights. Mosby says she wants juveniles who are being interviewed by police or prosecutors to have the right to have their parent and lawyer present.

Since 2015, the Conviction Integrity Unit has gotten a court to exonerate nine people wrongfully convicted.